Karate and the martial arts are much like other fitness regimes with roots in oriental mysticism; some forms incorporate more of the spiritual aspects than others with much of this depending on the whim of the instructor.
In an article he wrote about the different forms of the martial arts, B. J. Oropeza, a professor at the C. P. Haggard School of Theology at Azusa Pacific University, names Aikido, Ninjitsu, and Tai Chi as the most incompatible with Christianity.
Aikido means "the way to union with the universal force", with this force being known as "chi." Christians do not believe in, nor does science support, the concept of a "universal force" so a practitioner of Aikido is ultimately uniting himself or herself with a false god.
Ninjitsu is another form that is not compatible with Christianity. As Prof. Oropeza describes: "The Ninja tries to assimilate himself with nature in order to be more stealthy, and has a pantheistic worldview which believes all is God. The Christian believes that God is not the universe, but the Creator of the universe (Gen. 1:1-2)"
Tai Chi is off-limits because it involves the practice of Taoism. "In order to achieve physical well being, the Tai Chi student must be attuned to the universe by concentrating below the navel section of the body - which is said to be the body's psychic center," Prof. Oropeza writes. "Tai Chi cannot be reconciled with Christianity."
There are many other forms, such as Judo and Jujitsu, and Tae Kwon Do (Korean karate) that have a low spiritual emphasis.
Karate, on the other hand, requires meditation, which usually involves emptying the mind of distractions. "It is at this point that Karate becomes spiritually dangerous," Prof. Oropeza writes, but adds that since karate is primarily a physical martial art, the meditation aspect can be divorced from it.
Herein lies the "rub" when it comes to fitness regimes that have eastern roots. The spiritual aspects can be divorced from the practice, but are they? Is it enough that the non-Christian element may - or may not be - left out? Is it wise to leave so much up to the whim of an instructor?
For the most part, we're on our own when it comes to discernment in these classes. Are we up to the task? Are we well-armed and well-practiced in our faith?
It's no secret that the last two generations of Americans are not very well catechized. This means that the average person entering a fitness/martial arts class probably can't name the three theological virtues let alone distinguish between an eastern and a Christian meditation technique. Spiritually speaking, they probably are not developed enough to make the kind of distinctions they need to make in order to safely navigate these courses.
Not that we're "talking down" to anyone. We're just being realistic when we admit this. But more importantly, we're being charitable. Scripture teaches us to respect where other people are in their faith and to be willing to meet them on their own level, not our own (Romans 15).
Even though karate and the martial arts are popular ways of teaching children discipline, self-esteem and confidence, Christianity does the same thing, only without the violence and the risk to the soul.
Do you have a question about the New Age? Send it to us firstname.lastname@example.org and we'll post the answer right here on this blog!