EWTN Sues Government Over HHS Mandate

The Eternal Word Television Network (EWTN) is refusing to allow the government to force it to either stop providing insurance to its employees or use donor funds to pay for insurance coverage of drugs and procedures that violate Church teaching, and has filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court in Birmingham, Alabama to stop the imposition of the controversial mandate.

“We had no other option but to take this to the courts,” says EWTN President and CEO Michael P. Warsaw in a press release. “Under the HHS mandate, EWTN is being forced by the government to make a choice: either we provide employees coverage for contraception, sterilization and abortion-inducing drugs and violate our conscience or offer our employees and their families no health insurance coverage at all. Neither of those choices is acceptable.” 

The lawsuit was filed on EWTN‘s behalf by Mark Rienzi, Kyle Duncan, and Erik Kniffin from the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty.  

“We are taking this action to defend not only ourselves but also to protect other institutions — Catholic and non-Catholic, religious and secular — from having this mandate imposed upon them,” Warsaw continued. “The government is forcing EWTN, first, to inform its employees about how to get contraception, sterilization and abortifacient drugs, a concept known as forced speech.

“To make the matter worse, the government then will force EWTN to use its donors’ funds to pay for these same morally objectionable procedures or to pay for the huge fines it will levy against us if we fail to provide health care insurance. There is no question that this mandate violates our First Amendment rights. This is a moment when EWTN, as a Catholic organization, has to step up and say that enough is enough. Our hope is that our lawsuit does just that.”  

The Becket Fund previously filed similar lawsuits on behalf of Belmont Abbey College, a small Catholic liberal arts college in Belmont, N.C., and Colorado Christian University, an interdenominational Christian liberal arts university near Denver, which demonstrates that this is not just a Catholic issue. Both suits were filed prior to the HHS rules being finalized in January.  

“When the government recently mandated that all private group health plans cover certain abortion drugs (namely, Plan B and ella), as well as related education and counseling, [our clients] knew that they could not obey both the government’s mandate and their own religious convictions,” said Rienzi, who focuses his practice at the Becket Fund on violations of the Fourteenth Amendment, free speech, and the free exercise of religion. “The mandate has been sharply criticized from across the political spectrum, and from religious leaders of a variety of faiths.”  

Duncan, a former Louisiana Solicitor General and General Counsel of the Becket Fund, said that without a change in the rules, EWTN could be forced to pay more than $600,000 for the “privilege” of not underwriting these services.

“This mandate is particularly hard on Catholics because Catholic organizations, such as hospitals, schools, social service agencies, media outlets and others, serve people regardless of their religious beliefs,” Warsaw said. “We serve others not because they are Catholic, but because we are Catholic.”

2 Response to “EWTN Sues Government Over HHS Mandate

  1. I FULLY SUPPORT EWTN’s suit against HHS. Forcing EWTN – or ANY organization of conscience – to choose between God’s Law and “politically correct,” government-mandated law is a violation of our First Amendment Right of the separation of Church and State. And, in the case of EWTN, the issue entends further to the rights of donors of conscience who SHOULD BE ABLE TO EXPECT that their donations be used as they specify, and not to further HHS-mandated law that is contrary to Catholic teaching. EWTN is being placed in the untenible position of choosing between God’s Law and secular law as promulgated by HHS. HHS is illegally forcing a religious organization to use funds in MORALLY OBJECTIONABLE ways which are contrary to the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church whose principles they follow. THIS IS A MORAL OUTRAGE. Our secular government is CASTING ASIDE our FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT of the separation of Church and State. I respectfully request that HHS REMOVE their requirement that church organizations be forced to offer contraceptive devices, information and procedures, or to use their donors’ money for the same, in contradiction to that organization’s spiritual and moral beliefs.