Vatican to Rule on McCarrick Case This Month

It is expected that the case involving disgraced former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick who is accused of various incidents of sexual abuse over the past 50 years, will be decided by the Vatican before the February 21-24 bishops summit on clerical abuse.

Crux’s John L. Allen, Jr. is reporting that, according to various sources, McCarrick is set to lose his clerical status, which is more commonly known as being “laicized” or “defrocked.” This is the most severe punishment that can be imposed on a priest and is usually reserved for especially heinous offenses.

McCarrick, who is accused of the sexual abuse of a 16-year-old boy more than 50 years ago as well as various other incidents involving adult priests and seminarians, already received a highly unusual sanction in July 2018 when he was stripped of the title of Cardinal, making him the first prelate in a century to lose his red hat.

“Assuming the laicization happens, he would also be the highest-ranking Catholic cleric in modern times to suffer that penalty,” Allen writes.

Although sources say that the Pope and his Vatican team want the McCarrick case to be resolved before the upcoming summit, Allen warns that this will not be the end of the issue. Defrocking McCarrick would certainly show that the pope means business, but it leaves unresolved the most pressing issue surrounding this case – the cover up.

How did McCarrick get away with this behavior all these years? Who knew about it and when did they know it? And how could someone with his history have risen to such high levels in the Church hierarchy?

“What’s angered people from the beginning about the McCarrick scandal isn’t simply the pattern of behavior that’s been exposed, which may be especially galling because it involves an ex-cardinal but which, in itself, is sadly familiar,” Allen writes. “What’s created the deep sense of frustration one senses at the Catholic grassroots is the perception that senior authority figures in the Church were aware of concerns about McCarrick but continued to move him up the ladder, often for reasons of politics and self-interest.”

What the Catholic faithful really want is full disclosure. “ . . .[W]ho knew what, and when – who propelled his rise to power, and what did they know about the rumors and reports concerning McCarrick at the time?” Allen asks.

The Vatican is clearly aware of this and promised a “thorough study of the entire documentation present in the archives of the dicasteries and offices of the Holy See” because “both abuse and its cover-up can no longer be tolerated.”

As Allen concludes, “If Francis and his advisers want the McCarrick case to be wrapped up before the summit later this month, therefore, just laicizing him won’t do the trick. They’ll also need to explain how we got to a point where such a move is necessary – and, of course, offer some reason to believe we won’t be here again.”

Let us keep all those involved in this matter, including Theodore McCarrick and his victims, in our prayers!

© All Rights Reserved, Living His Life Abundantly®/Women of Grace®

For more information on how you can support our priests during this troubling time, visit the Foundation of Prayer for Priests.


Comments are closed.